Idaho's Polly Bemis was the Pacific Northwest's most famous Chinese American woman, overcoming the fact that "Orientals" (Asians/Chinese) were not well respected in mining camps. Her reputation were comparable to others in her hometown's (Warren) storied past that also revolved around other characters of the time and place named Judge Poe, Three-Fingered Jack and Cougar Dave.
Polly Bemis (Lalu Nathoy) was born on September 11,1853, in Northern China (apart from the many other Chinese that came from Southern China/Canton), near one of the upper rivers.
Lalu's impoverished farmer parents had her feet had been bound as if she were from a family of means, then unbound. When Lalu was eighteen, a prolonged drought forced her father was forced to sell her to bandits in exchange for enough seed to plant another crop to save his family. It is reported that when the bandits take her away from home, she was not obedient and stoop to them while trying many times to escape from the bandits as many times as she can. It is reported that she let (Chen), the leader of the bandits, keep her for himself as a wife instead of making her a common whore.
Through Shanghai (China), San Francisco (United States) and Idaho City (United States) - she arrived at Warrens (a rip-roaring camp - northeast of McCall - during the Gold Rush days that started in 1861 in Idaho), where the bandit (Hong King) either died or deserted Polly while operating a restaurant/dance hall/saloon/gambling house for several years. Polly, however, stated "Old woman smuggle me into Portland. I cost $2,500. . . . Old Chineeman he took me to Warrens in a pack train."
According to reports, Polly gained her freedom long before she married Bemis, "Big Jim was sitting out in front of his place one afternoon, sunning himself, when he suddenly toppled over. He was dead when he was picked up. The doctor said it was his heart. As a result, Polly and the other girls no longer belonged to anyone. For four of the five, it was just a matter of changing hands, and they continued their whoring. Polly opened a little restaurant and did well until she fell in love with Charley Bemis."
For Chinese men, not only were there not Chinese women here, but they also had laws that forbid interracial marriage between Chinese and whites. It creates a situation where there are criminal Tongs, secret societies, set up where they could bring these girls to who had been sold by their parents to the United States and women were literary sold into prostitution.
Some of the women tried to run away with the help of men who befriended them or who loved them. The only other way and some of the women did this, was to commit suicide rather than continue to work and endure these conditions as a sex slave.
|
There is also another story. Acknowledging that the Chinese women who labored as prostitutes, the majority worked as chattel for masters who'd bought them. Beginning in 1861, California passed a series of codes aimed at restricting the importation of Chinese women for prostitution that motivated the smuggling trade between "importers" (often Chinese) and recruiting agents. She could have followed the paths of other Chinese women where she stayed at San Francisco's Chinatown (in barracoons) where enslaved Chinese women were either held while awaiting distribution or auctioned off to the highest bidder. This would result in her traveling by boat up the Columbia River from Portland to Lewiston, Idaho, and then by pack train to Warrens.
Pioneers A. W. Talkington stated "Polly was a good woman and entitled to a good deal of consideration because of her upright conduct in rather difficult circumstances" and George Bancroft claimed "got money from women's time-honored methods." Other pioneers insisted Polly had never worked as a prostitute. "Polly Nathoy was brought from China to Warrens for the world's oldest profession. When taken to (Hong King's) saloon, she was terrified! Charlie Bemis was present and protected her from unwanted advances." (Bertha Long)
Polly's longing for freedom is seen as she determines to buy herself back from the whore house; saves money for her freedom when she is sold to the saloon; even tries to kill Hong King, her master, to make herself free. When Charlie wins her from Hong King in a card game, she doesn't feel happy or grateful but angry that Charlie "forces her to break her promise that when she leaves Hong King, she would become a free woman." She doesn't want to belong to Charlie though he loves her and will never make her a slave. She wants to be a self-sufficient woman with her own business, a boarding house. For the desire for independence, Polly has refused three times Charlie's proposal of marriage and still keeps her own place after eighteen years of living with him.
On July 8, 1872 - Charles Bemis (whose "fearless personality, coupled with his skill at shooting, enabled him to maintain order without getting into trouble owned the saloon and was the town's deputy sheriff) bought Lalu from the Chinese owner (Hong King) as payment resulting from a poker game (according to legend) - who was introduced as "Polly" and thereafter was called by this name as his "poker bride."
LIFE IN WARRENS
In its heyday, the population of Warrens reached 3,000, roughly
one third of which were Chinese who had relocated after the railroads
were complete. There wasn't a single white woman in the camp which
was rife with violence and bloodletting. Probably because of the
rough passage, the women were all either Lapwai (Sheepeater) Native
American girls, stolen or possibly purchased from their tribe, or
Chinese slaves owned by "Big Jim," the boss of the Chinese colony.
He worked his slaves as prostitutes. The most famous of these was
China Polly, who Big Jim had bought, along with four other women,
in San Francisco, taking them first to Idaho City and eventually
downriver to Warrens. |
|
Polly
was just one of fifty Chinese in Warrens who pleaded not guilty
to "the alleged violation of Section 6 of Act November 3rd, 1893
of the Statutes of the United States."
All fifty blamed their failure to register on the government official's
inability to come to Warrens as promised because "the roads were
impassible owing to the snows and rains and they were represented
by the same attorney, D. Worth." |
All the descriptions of Polly in her youth remark on her beauty, and she was renowned even in her old age for her wit and charm. By the 1880s they were living together. Polly remained financially independent on Bemis (who died in October 29,1922) by taking in laundry from miners and ran a boardinghouse.
After living together for years, they were married in 1894 after Idaho modified its law against mixed-race unions. Some say as the result of Polly's medical care (with the assistance of Al Kan/Lee Dick - credited as "healers") resulting from an injury resulting from a poker game with John Cox, above-listed "poker bride" and/or the result of the 1895's Geary Act that required Chinese legally residing in the United States to carry a certificate of residence at all times.
The couple was renowned for their generous hospitality with Polly's bright-eyed warmth and humor - whether injured, ill and/or nursing them back to health. As pioneer John Carrey put it, "There was nobody in my day who carried the respect Polly earned through her kindness to everybody." The Bemis ranch became known as Polly Place, and a overnment survey party named the creek running through the property for Polly in 1911.
On May 13,1896, the case United States v Polly Bemiss [sic], (one of fifty Chinese who pleaded not guilty to the "alleged violation of Section 6 of Act November 3rd, 1893 of the Statutes of the United States") in the matter of the arrest and deportation of said defendant, was heard in Moscow, Idaho. As required by law, Polly had a white witness who testified that she had already been living in the United States when the Geary Act passed, that she was a "peaceable law abiding Chinaman, inoffensive, and has been continuously engaged in laundrying [sic] for ten years in Idaho County." Her witness was a resident of Grangeville, and his testimony was given on May 7,1896, before W. A. Hall, U.S. Circuit Court Commissioner for the District of Idaho. Polly also presented testimony before Hall that same day.
Although Polly is a woman with strength and courage, she was afraid of having children. What she's worrying about was not about herself but the children. She believed that her children, who would be Chinese-Americans, would live under racism and violence against the Asians.
Polly died at 3:00 A.M. on November 6,1933 and buried at Grangeville's Prairie View Cemetery.
In 1987 the Department of the Interior deemed the cabin significant in Idaho's heritage, and at the museum's dedication ceremonies Governor Cecil Andrus declared, "The history of Polly Bemis is a great part of the legacy of central Idaho. She is the foremost pioneer on the rugged Salmon River."